Salmons Brook

Environment Agency work about to start but nobody has told Grange Park

on Monday, 18 February 2013. Posted in Salmons Brook

Print

The Environment Agency is about to start work on the Salmos Brook Flood Alleviation Project in Cheyne Park, on Wedensday February 20th, according to a newsletter that the EA sent to various Enfield councillors and council officials but NOT to the local residents of Grange Park. This letter written by a local resident to the Planning Department and the Environment Agency explains how they are defaulting on their legal obligations.
 
 To quote:
"It is my understanding that Planning Consent was given by the Council to the above scheme on 7 February and I have now had an opportunity to scrutinise the formal notice online.  This gives rise to certain issues, as follows:-
 
1.       I was under the impression that the Council have a responsibility to advise stakeholders, particularly those residents who responded as part of the consultation process, of the outcome of the planning application.  This does not appear to have happened and it brings into question as how you propose to communicate the conditions attached to the planning consent.  These are of great interest and importance to local residents who will be seriously affected over an extended period by the proposed  works and the associated traffic movements through the local roads.  It is vital that the Environment Agency are held to account for the conditions imposed upon them in the planning consent and residents should be made aware of them. 
 
2.       There are several conditions which need to be fulfilled before work can commence on site including the obligation in Condition 22 to give 28 days notice of the commencement of any site works to all occupiers adjacent to the site.  The EA have prepared a Newsletter (dated February), available online but not as yet distributed to local residents, which states that site clearance works, including tree removal, will commence on 20 February.  Clearly, they seem comfortable in commencing these works without giving 28 days notice as they state that these works are permitted development and, by inference, do not fall within the scope of the planning consent for the scheme as a whole. This displays a degree of arrogance on the part of the Environment Agency and perhaps gives an indication of how they propose to treat local residents during the progress of the scheme.  The operative words in the planning consent are “any site works” and it is my view that these words mean just that, irrespective of whether or not there is a convenient legal technicality which lets the Environment Agency off the hook for complying with the spirit of the conditions imposed.  Would it not be unreasonable to expect them to have a duty of care to engage with stakeholders and residents and a moral obligation to give 28 days notice, apart from relying on a strict interpretation of the conditions imposed by the Council?
 
3.        A further relevant point is that it would be reasonable to assume that there will be considerable vehicular movements to and from Enfield Golf Course/Cheyne Walk Open Space via the local estate roads during the site clearance works.  Will these works be bound by the several conditions imposed in the Planning Consent relating to the movement of traffic to and from the site?  Or are the Environment Agency relying again on their permitted development powers to absolve themselves from any responsibility in this respect?
 
4.       Would the Council have any powers, either as Planning Authority or landowners, to delay the implementation of the site clearance works until such time as the Environment Agency have given reasonable and proper notice to residents of their intended works?
 
Having regard to the sensitivity of this scheme and the previous concerns raised by local residents in the Grange Park area, the Environment Agency have got off to a bad start on this scheme which does not bode well for the future. I would welcome your comments, please, on the issues I have raised".
 
AB, Grange Park Resident
 
Yet again Grange Park residents are being kept int he dark about issues which haev a major impact on their lives and our local habit. 
 
Read the Environment Agency's February 2013 newsletter here

Salmons Brook Planning Application passed

on Tuesday, 13 November 2012. Posted in Salmons Brook

Print

Enfield Council Planning Committee have approved the Environment Agency's Salmons Brook Flood Alleviation Scheme.

 

Voting on party lines, sadly this had become a political East/West, Left/Right issue.The Grange Park protesters are not against flood alleviation schemes per se, have sympathies for residents who have been flooded, but concerned about the way this one was foistered on Grange Park, without due consideration of the residents, their property or whether there could be alternative ways of alleviating the flood risk in Edmonton, which might be cheaper and more equitable solutions.

 

There were no concessions, Uplands Way will bear the brunt of the traffic. Work begins in the Spring.This Grange Park resident sums up the situation very succintly.

 

"As a Grange Park resident I would like to thank all those involved in opposing the EA's SBFAS application. Perhaps when the scheme is implemented the apathetic majority will appreciate the huge amount of time and effort these people invested in trawling through the detail. Their challenge against the huge resources of the EA and Council should be applauded; it is a shame for Grange Park that this process was seemingly ultimately pre determined. Although never about party politics, the fact that planning committee voting went with party lines is disappointing. Unfortunately for the people of Enfield, the Labour led Council administration's  approval of this scheme marks at best a questionable approach to financial expenditure. This is particularly concerning bearing in mind the current constraints on the public purse; perhaps this will be remembered by the voting majority at the next opportunity".


More details can be found on the Grange Park At Risk website http://gpar.org.uk/


The Salmons Brook Project could affect you

on Friday, 02 November 2012. Posted in Salmons Brook

Print

This leaflet was circualted across 1,000 households in Grange Park during the week of October 29th 2012.

 

If you didn't receive it, you may still want to lodge an objection to the project.

 

You can read some of the technical argeuments underpinning this campaign on the N21nline.com message board, using this link

 

 

 

Ten Reasons Why Enfield Council Planning Committee Should Reject The Salmon's Brook Flood Alleviation Planning Application

on Friday, 09 November 2012. Posted in Salmons Brook

Print

 
 
 
  1. There are concerns that DEFRA was given misleading funding to secure the priority funding for the Salmons Brook Flood Alleviation Project. Is the scheme really required,in this day and age is it money we can afford?
  2. Analysis of data suggests that the modelling and statistical data used for the modelling is flawed.
  3. There has been inadequate consideration given to alternative options.
  4. The consultation has been flawed from the beginning, The Environment Agency project team seem unable (to unwilling) to respond to questions.
  5. The Planning application has not been available on the Council website for the statutory period of time, due to broken links.
  6. The Cheyne Walk Open Space was designated a Site of Importance For Nature Conservation (SINC) by Enfield Council in November 2011.
  7. The EA have not taken seriously residents' concerns, including the need for structural surveys along the route in Grange Park, where damage is highly likely to properties, roads, kerbs & trees. Without surveys, it will be very difficult for residents to seek compensation.
  8. The revised traffic management plan with a two way movement of lorries along Uplands Way is intolerable for people living in Uplands Way and there has been no risk assessment on health and safety no consideration given to local population of children and elderly.
  9. Little consideration for road safety, for school children or cyclists, especially on dangerous junctions such as Mason's Corner
  10. There has been no further flooding since 2000, the Environment Agency allowed planning permission to lapse in 2005 - SO, WHY THE RUSH?

 

READ SOME OF THE OBJECTIONS SUBMITTED TO ENFIELD COUNCIL HERE

 

READ DAVID BURROWES'S ONJECTIONS HERE

Grange Park At Risk

on Thursday, 25 October 2012. Posted in Salmons Brook

Print

 

 

 

CLICK ON THE IMAGE FOR UP TO DATE NEWS ON SALMONS BROOK FLOOD ALLEVIATION SCHEME AND THE FORTHCOMING PUBLIC MEETING

Salmons Brook Project amended route to site

on Monday, 24 September 2012. Posted in Salmons Brook

Print

 

Read the revised route proposals, which have been submitted to Enfield Council here

 

Environment Agency Salmons Brook Planning Presentation July 2012

on Thursday, 12 July 2012. Posted in Salmons Brook

Print

 

Click on the image to view the presentation

 

Read a statement from David Burrowes & the Grange Ward councillors here

Enfield Golf Club's position on Environmental Agency's proposals

on Tuesday, 05 June 2012. Posted in Salmons Brook

Print

 
Enfield Golf Club (EGC) objects to the grant of planning permission to the Environment Agency (EA) unless changes are made that will protect EGC’s vital interests. The changes requested (which are the subject of investigation by the EA) are, most importantly, the provision of additional storage for flood water upstream of the proposed Bund and changes to the proposed flume. Furthermore, the application is deficient in the information given concerning short term flooding and in drawings showing the full impact of the land shaping proposed on the Golf Course. Until all these issues are agreed with the EA it is strongly urged that no decision is made on the application.
 
Enfield Golf Club has grave concerns for the future of the Club if the scheme is implemented without measures being taken to protect us against new, excessive and frequent flooding in the future as a result of the work. We are seeking amendments to the scheme designed to protect the course in the event of low level flooding events which for this purpose we will treat as predicted floods ranging from a 1 in 1 year scenario, up to 1 in 5 years.  These would happen here on the course even when there is no risk of flooding at Montagu Road which in 2000 was a 1 in 20/25 year event.  It does not seem unreasonable to ask that amendments be made that will benefit the Club whilst not affecting the objective of the scheme.
 

Planning Application for Salmons Brook Flood Alleviation Scheme

on Monday, 21 May 2012. Posted in Salmons Brook

Print

Dear Neighbour
 
Consultation letters regarding the above have been sent out to some properties in Uplands Way – but not all! The deadline for any comments about the scheme is 28th May.   Full details of the scheme are available to view on the Enfield Council Planning Department website, using the Application Ref shown. If you have any concerns at all about the scheme you must voice your objections now – and you should include the fact that you have not received official consultation documents, if that is the case.

 

Environment Agency submits planning application for Salmons Brook Flood Alleviation Scheme

on Monday, 14 May 2012. Posted in Salmons Brook

Print

 
Salmons Brook, Enfield, N21, N9, N18.  Flood Alleviation Works involving flood storage at Enfield Golf Course, comprising new embankment; flood defences along Salmons, Walk, Lower Edmonton, comprising raised flood defences between Plevna Road and Montagu Road and new culvert under Montagu Road; flood storage at Montague Recreation Ground, comprising new embankment; and mitigation works to Salmons Brook adjacent to Buury Lodge Park comprising river channel improvement works
 
Yesterday (11.5.12) we received official notification of receipt of the Planning Application above with the invitation to comment to the Planning Department within 21 days of the date of the letter (8.5.12).
 
 

 

SALMONS BROOK FLOOD ALLEVIATION CONSULTATION

on Tuesday, 27 March 2012. Posted in Salmons Brook

Print

The Environment Agency held an exhibition at Highlands School on March 27th to provide an update on the Salmons Brook Flood Alleviation Scheme.  This is an opportunity for local residents to meet members of the team and council representatives.

 

The exhibition was well attended with many local residents expressing concern about the project, in particular the prospect of around 60 heavy lorries a day travelling both ways along Uplands Way. It is not just the congestion that is a worry but also the vibrations which could result in structural damage. This is a problem that the Environmental Agency are anticipating as they have agreed to undertake structural surveys on properties in proximity to the site, prior to the work starting, which would become a starting point for further monitoring.

SALMONS BROOK FLOOD ALLEVIATION UPDATE

on Thursday, 22 September 2011. Posted in Salmons Brook

Print

Despite the Environmental Agency’s stated plan to apply to Enfield Council for planning permission to begin work on the Salmons Brook Flood Alleviation Scheme this Autumn, it has just been announced that no planning application will now be made until the Spring of 2012, which will push the start date for the work back to the second half of 2012.

 

This a major project, which will impact on residents, in particular the allotment holders on Cheyne Walk, Worlds End Lane and also Enfield Golf Club. The Environment Agency plans to build a new embankment to store floodwater during periods of high water flow, to reduce the risk of flooding further downstream in Edmonton.  The work will entail heavy lorries on our local roads, not dissimiliar to the recent Network Rail work, through residential Grange Park roads.

SALMONS BROOK FLOOD ALLEVIATION SCHEME NEWSLETTER

on Friday, 13 May 2011. Posted in Salmons Brook

Print

 

CLICK ON THE IMAGE BELOW TO DOWN THE LATEST ENVIRONMENT AGENCY SALMONS BROOK FLOOD ALLEVIATION SCHEME